Not recommended at all...
SMUDGES all over the eyelids!! I was very disappointed with this mascara... it doesn't seem to dry very well and sticks my eye lashes together... it doesn't do a good job in volumizing them at all (Rimmel's mascara does much better job at that and is cheaper!). I went on a clubbing night out and, as I never had to worry before about 'panda eyes', I didn't pay much attention to my make up. I went to toilet after an hour of dancing and, oh my world! I wish somebody had told me I had this mascara all over my upper and lower eye lid!!
Worst mascara I've ever used, doesn't dry and is a waste of money.
It is a lovely mascara but I found that during the day it would flake away and leave marks below my eyes. I've ended up using one of the other mascara's instead.
Have used the volumising mascara and loved it so I thought I would try this one for a change. Very disappointed as it smudges continually. Contacted Soap and Glory who said they are aware of the problem and advised me to return it to Boots where I exchanged it for the volumising one again. It's a pity they don't withdraw it until they get it right!
The best mascara i've used in ages love it
I think it's fantastic on my second one now !
Honestly the worst mascara i have ever used, it was too wet and gloopy sticking all my eyelashes together, it wouldnt dry and so i ended up removing it from my face and binning it. Very Gutted especially as i have just wasted another 10 pounds down the drain, would not at all reccomend
This mascara is awfull it's sticky it's smudges all the time and doesn't dry! The brush goes really clumpy and it's makes your lashes stick together safe to say I won't be using it agin.
I won't buy it again .... It's in the bin... £10.50 wasted
I love s and glory products but this mascara is terrible... It just doesn't dry.. And I ended up with panda eyes within an hour... I've used the one in the black tube snd that was fine..
This really let me down i was so happy about this product coming on sale and like said above for the price i paid i wasn't satisfied would not recommend this product
I was really excited to buy this, as i shop in soap and glory all the time. I should have just stayed with my old and trustworthy loreal mascara. I was fairly disappointed, and i buy a lot of make up products. It's such a shame as well, because Soap and Glory are one of my favourite brands! Bummer!
Basically I ended up with Panda type looking eyes by the end of the day.
This was a real let down for the price.
I honestly thought this was brilliant? I never had any dark circles or anything even after having 4 hours of dance. Made my lashes huge and filled! Love this!
do not recommend! leaves huge black smudge marks under eyes!! also doesnt give the extension effect it states :( probably the worst mascara i've ever used to be honest, will not be using this again!
Not cheap but now sits in the drawer after one use.
So disappointing, love Soap and Glory and mascara did as stated and pleased with lashes BUT so embarrassed as wore out for a lunch and on visiting the loo was horrified with black rings above and below the eyes, made worse when trying to clean up. I looked ill :(
Poor quality for a high price! Was very surprised as I usually LOVE Soap and Glory Products. Smudges even after hours of wear and leaves me with black panda looking eyes at the end of the day.
Unfortunately this mascara is awful. I find it goes in fine, but within an hour it has smudged all under my eyes and I look like a panda. I have had so many people comment on how bad it is in just the two days I have worn it! Definitely not good when you need to have a professional appearance.
I would consider trying one of the other mascara's but am loath to potentially waste another £10. I may instead 'play it safe' and go back to buying all my make up from Rimmel and Maybelline.
I am so disappointed in this mascara! I had recently converted to Soap and Glory mascara after finding the skincare so good.
Love this mascara really lengthens lashes and allows you to build volume at the roots really easily! Make up staple :0)
For every day use the regular one is fab, and for thicker lashes, the collagen mascara works really well. However, this one makes my lashes sooo long! The first couple of times I used it, the mascara was a bit clumpy but it seems to have blended in a bit now.
It comes off really well with removal wipes and doesn't leave smudginess under my eyes like a lot of mascaras do. I've got super sensitive eyes too and it doesn't irritate them at all.
Fantastic S&G.. yet another win for you :)
I've now tried all of the thick and fast mascaras and am so far finding this one to be the best for how I like my lashes to look.
I personally didn't find that it smudged at all (apart from the time I forgot to take it off before bed...whoops).
I found it helped to enhance my lashes making them longer & much more noticeable. I did find, that I had to wait for the first coat to apply before adding a second but apart from that I love, Love, LOVE it!
I used this mascara after a friend of mine recommended it & I absolutely love it.
As a 19 year old, I use a lot of beauty products, mascara in particular and have tried a variety of different brands. This is by far the worst mascara I have ever bought. Shadowing the viewpoints of the other reviews I have read, the mascara is clumpy and does take a long time to dry. Although I have not had any problems with 'panda eyes', I have after taking the mascara off noticed swelling and redness around my eye area - again I have not had problems with this when using other products. I personally would not recommend this product.
I found this mascara to give my lashes a very natural look. I wouldn't say its thick or volumising. However I do like it for the fact that I can get a natural look from it. I like the brush which is a big round soft brush, much better then the comb type. I got this in one of the gift packs but not sure if I would feel differently if I had specifically gone to buy the product.
I am surprised with the other reviews as I have found this to be one of the best mascaras I have ever used I haven't found it at all clumpy. I find it comes out of the tube evenly and goes smoothly onto my eyelashes making them look great. I would like to add that I normally use much more expensive mascaras and will be buying this one again. Double thumbs up
Don't think I have ever given a bad review on anything, but this mascara is terrible, don't think I have ever had such a bad product, not worth 50p never mind £10.50. You end up with panda eyes and working with the public this was very embarrassing . One word for it RUBBISH !!
As someone who owns every soap and glory product ever made, I am SO DISAPPOINTED with this mascara!!! Smudges after a few hours, doesn't do much to eyelashes and generally feels cheap! Go for the original mascara instead!
If I haven't made it clear - I think this mascara sucks and I wouldn't recommend it to my next door neighbour (who is really noisy and inconsiderate).
Please, S&G, fix this situation.
I love S&G...There isn't enough power in my laptop to tell you just how much. Unfortunately, this is the ONE product that I don't like one wee bit. It makes me sad because I want to like it, I really really do. I also want to not be annoyed that I bought it, but it's too late for that carry on.
I normally love soap and glory. I had the gold mascara which is my second favourite to they're real. This though, is the worst mascara I have ever used. Goes everywhere. Clumpy. Takes ages to dry. I don't understand because the gold one is great!
Really dissapointing. Within half an hour of applying i look like a panda!. I always love soap and glory products and they always do what they say on the tin, not this!.
I use this mascara every day & love it!! Well done S&G another great product.
I bought this as I love both the other S&G mascaras but feel massively let down by this product. It does look good at first but smudges really badly after a couple of hours, feels tacky and clumps together toward the end of the day. Really not worth the money and will stick to the two other mascaras instead.
A W F U L stuff! Horrible horrible horrible, S&G you have definitely gone downhill!
I bought this mascara a few days ago because I love the other soap and glory mascaras. However, I was really unimpressed with this one. Within an hour of putting it on, most of it was under my eyes. It didn't last long at all! I use soap and glory a lot, and this is the first time i have ever had to give something a bad review.