The reason why reviews for this eyeliner are so different is probably because this eyeliner is really good but obviously not suitable for everyone' skin texture. I first bought it years ago and was very pleasantly surprised with it's blackness and durability of the product. Since I don't live in UK, it lasted almost til my next visit when I repurchased (about 9-10 months). Love it but can't get to it now since soapandglory.com don't post to Croatia and it's such a shame.
This is a lovely eyeliner, it applies REALLY well... The only problem I am having is with its scent. It makes my eyes water and hard to keep open, I've only worn it twice and I've had to remove it twice as my eyes went puffy, streaming with tears and sore from the strong odour! It's a real shame as it's easy to use and the colour is perfect.
Really disappointed with this. When I first used it, it went on perfectly and stayed on the whole night however despite me putting the cap on right away and storing it as suggested it had dried up by the second time I came to use it. I have tried storing it tip down to no avail. Complete rip off, would not recommend.
Such precision and the best eyeliner I have come across so far. It has lasted me so long, and even stays on your eyes for long too! An intense deep black and great for either a natural or dramatic look.
This eyeliner is really easy to apply and is incredibly pigmented however it tends to smudge and transfer after a couple of hours.
Always leaves me with smudges under my eyes, and while it is easy to apply and full of colour, it fades after a few hours. I don't have an oily complexion, so it is disappointing, but I will try with a primer under. Love their Archery brow tint and pen though!
I have used gel liner for a couple of years and never really tried a pen before so I thought I'd give it a go as I thought it would be easier to use on holiday. I have not gone back to the gel liner since, this is so easy to use with no dragging on the skin and if you make a mistake its so easy to remove! The only reason I wouldn't give this a five is that sometimes I find I have to go over the line twice to get a full colour, otherwise this product is great!
Awful. Saw someone applying this on the underground and looked impressive. I asked where she purchased her eyeliner from and she said 'Boots'. Was looking forward to using product, I found it extremely hard to apply not smooth at all; results are terrible, by the time the afternoon came I had two black smudges. Disappointed...yes. Would I recommend this product...no.
Love this eye liner, no smudges, easy to apply in a straight line and lasts a very long time. I can't rate this highly enough.
I absolutely love this eyeliner - its by far my favourite after using many many products. It's great for beginners and even experts. I would say the only downside is that Soap and Glory doesn't ship internationally so I can't get my hands on this brilliant eyeliner easily.
I really like this eyeliner, it's easy to use and and doesn't fade. My only issue is it will smudge a bit over the day but i've never found that to be a huge issue. It's a definite repurchase for me :)
Love this eyeliner, used with a eye primer and shadow it stays for hours. I agree with some that it does smudge but I've only found this on a bare eyelid. I love this product and use it a lot with different looks.
100% the best liquid liner I have tried so far and will definitely be buying it again! It is super easy to apply and looks flawless every time. The only downfall is that it does not react well to water, when my eyes water it smudges everywhere and sometimes gets into my eyes and hurts SO much. However I'd still recommend.
I have tried so many different eyeliners but this is without a doubt my favourite!
I couldn't recommend this enough, I use it every single day and it lasts for ages.
Such a smooth application and so easy to use.
I loveee this product.
Definitely recommend :)
Love this eyeliner! !. I think I've gone through every brand of eyeliner available and I just happened to stumble on this in boots one day and thought I'd give it a shot. The formula is really highly pigmented and it just glides on, no tugging on the lid which means you can just do a really precise flick in one sweep no hasale. It stays on pretty much all day but after a couple of hours it does start to fade especially at the corners, having said that it doesn't smudge or transfer when you rub your eye. For the £6 price tag it is a bargain compared to other eyeliners that are half as good for double the money!.
It's okay I mean I was expecting a lot more for the price but it comes out more grey than black and the actual flick that I do will fade after about 10 minutes so I'm not overly keen and a little disappointed that I spent £8 on it :\ oh well I'd better go to sleep now
Product isn't drying and applys well
Long wearing too
Product its self lasts long
Love this eyeliner! Easiest to apply that i've ever used! Only bad thing is it smudges easily (after a while) would buy again and again and again!
This was my holy grail eyeliner for over a year, but the last two I have purchased have applied almost grey and have dried out incredibly quickly. At £6 a go, I'm really disappointed. Has the formula been changed?
LOVE LOVE LOVE!! My favourite liquid eyeliner by far! It is so easy to apply and doesn't fade or smudge. Cute packaging as well :)
Have been using this for several years now. Have tried others just for a change, however keep coming back to this. Really nice application, wears well and lasts. Highly recommend.
This eyeliner is... okay. It's not amazing but it's not completely crap either. You could probably get a better one in Superdrug. This eyeliner is not worth £6 in my opinion.
Amazing product. Absolutely adore the pin up and vintage style packaging. Best eyeliner I have ever tried, as I've tried many due to having hooded eyes. Love it. <3
OMG! I love this eyeliner! It's so easy to apply and can do a thicker more dramatic line just as easy as a thinner one. It stays on really well and doesn't feel too sticky line some liners. Absolutely love this product, I will definately repurchase!
This is one of the best liquid pen eyeliners that I have found, and I have tried many! Its application is easy and the product usually lasts a night out but is also good for during the day too.
Really disappointed with this product. Goes on nice and easy and looks great but every time I use it I'm left with panda eyes after about 2 hours, it seems to always leak down below my bottom lash line and just looks horrible! So disappointed as usually Soap and Glory really deliver on their products but not this time. Will be returning to the trusty Rimmel liquid eyeliner.
Over the years I have spent a fortune searching for a really good eyeliner and now I have finally found one. Supercat goes on beautifully, lasts all day and into the evening. It's really easy to apply, I don't think I will ever use anything else ever again.
I really do not know what else to say - This liquid ''pen'' eyeliner is fantasic!
I am a girl of all things Retro - especially Rockabilly, so as you can imagine I love a strong pointed winged eyeliner and I have tried out MANY different liquid eyeliners but I am so happy I have now found Supercat!!!
Easy to apply! Long-lasting! Does not smudge! Creates the perfect flick!
What more could a girl want from liquid eyeliner...
LOVE LOVE LOVE LOVE LOVE!!
This eyeliner is amazing! I've tried liquid eyeliner before but that's really hard to control, but with this pen you can either make a thick line, or thin, depending on how you want it. Would definitely recommend!
This eyeliner is just unbelievable, I moved onto this from Rimmel's liquid eyeliner, which used to be so difficult to put on and would go everywhere! At first I really couldn't believe that liquid eyeliners could be this easy! It gives you amazing control. I can do a really super thin line when I want just a casual everyday look that won't smudge or fade like kohl, or I can make a hassle free cat flick. It lasts for ages too, I use mine I'd say about five times a week and I bought it in September -it's now March!
I love this eyeliner! It's definitely the best one I've ever owned. It's so easy to apply and can be used in so many different ways, it doesn't fade either which is perfect!
After trying to find the perfect eyeliner, i stumbled across this AMAZING soap and glory one. normally, i find it so hard to get the feline flick or do a thick line but this pen gives me control and i can draw perfect lines and they don't smudge! unlike others, supercat's brush doesn't spread or break and its good for soft and accurate application. i would give it 5 stars but it didn't stay as long as i expected it to, maybe 9 to 10 hours for me, however it is now my go-to product and its quick and easy to apply. GENUINELY AMAZE. its the best on the market and other competitors like loreal and bobbi brown need to learn a thing or too!
LOVE THIS SO MUCH- so easy and accurate to apply and colour stays all day with no smudging
After wanting a liquid effect eyeliner for my upper lashes without the hassle of either a gel or proper liquid, I heard about "felt tip" eyeliners. After trying a few, I thought the brushes became splayed and the colour would go on and look like a small child's colouring. Then I found this! Supercat stays all day looking like a liquid, and is easy enough to put on with one stroke. Best buy in my makeup bag, easily. BUY IT NOW!!! I wish I could vote 10 star for this fab product.
In LOVE with the product and WILL definatly be buying again
OMG by far the best eyeliner ive bought in 10 years, easy to put on deep black stays on all day and love the whole vintage style to the product
I'd recommend to anyone, I will defiantly buy another when this one runs out.
Where do I start? This eyeliner is absolutely amazing!! The price is cheap, packaging is snazzy and the eyeliner goes on easily, it's pure black and stays on all day!
This is THE BEST eyeliner pen EVER! As a Burlesque dancer, Rockabilly and retro enthusiast, jet black, winged liquid eyeliner is central to my look. I've used the most expensive brands and been disappointed with both colour and durability. Supercat has never failed me! Under stage lights, it's strong, glossy and long lasting. Love it!
I love love love this! It i my favourite make u item... it always makes me thing of basement jaxx, "not no super catch aint no model" cos it sounds similar! So easy to apply, i wear it every day!
It is also easy to apply if you have shaky hands (eg. when you're nervous... or drunk!) as it is just like a felt tip pen rather than a small paintbrush. Perfect item.
I agree with Rachel from Merseyside below! Previous to this, the only decent liquid eyeliner i could find was Rimmel but this one is even better as it goes on so easily & you don't have to fiddle around with a bottle or worry about knocking it over which is handy when you live with a mental puppy.
Best eyeliner I have ever used! I've always used Rimmel liquid eyeliner as it's the only good one I knew of that had a thick tip, but this one is even better as it goes on so easily and you don't have to fiddle about with a bottle as the liquid is already in the pen! Brilliant!
I do find this the most foolproof and hassle free liquid eyeliner I have. It is as black as black gets and the application is very precise and clean to do. Fantastic.
This eyeliner is perfect for any look specially cat-eyes, the felt tip applicator helps you create the perfect flick and eye liner line. It is extremely black and stays black all day.
I am very very happy with this product.
The Colour- Extremely black and stays black. Remains the colour when I put it over eye shadow.
Durability- This eyeliner stayed perfect all day and it didn't smudge. Although it isn't waterproof it hasn't yet run or should I say (ran down my face) in the English weather, but be careful!
I would and am defiantly buying this eyeliner again after it runs out! x
Being a huge lover of eyeliners and the 'cat-eyed' look, I brought this because of its name, Supercat.
Smudges? Never! I have used this loads it will only smudge before it is dry, which is less than a minute! Perhaps if you havn't let eye cream / cream shaddow soak in properly it will.
Really easy to use and gorgeous thick velvety black colour,
Make sure you store it correctly.
I have converted friends with this liner as soon as they tried mine they went to get some.
Love Love Love!!!
I'm baffled by all the 5 star reviews. This is the worst liquid eyeliner I've ever used, and I've tried many over the years - pen, brush, gel, cake - the lot. True liquid eyeliner with the brush is still my favourite for retro flicks, but I tried this as it was in a 3-for-2 deal. Even so, it's a ripoff. It smudges so easily, and I've got panda eyes within a couple of hours. The felt tip is admittedly better than most I've tried. It's just too bad the product itself is so useless.
Best eyeliner I have ever, ever used. In fact, I've even stockpiled a few in case of zombie apocalypse - I think I'd rather be pulled apart by the undead than be without this product. Easy to apply, great for vintage looking flicks and cat eyes, it's very dark in colour, applies well even over eyeshadow. Excellent. I love you Soap & Glory.
It worked really well on the first day, and on the second it was watery and pale and barely showed up at all. What a waste of money! I'm a student, with very little money in general - it takes me a while to save up for some new makeup and I may as well not have bothered. Very unimpressed.
Apart from it rubbing out and not coming out as good as it does on your hand (probs the gravity making the ink not go down when you hold it to your eye) when i need a new eye liner i will probably still get this, as although it can be an awkward bugger - i still love it!
This is a great EXTREME BLACK liner. I always have trouble matching up my flicks but with this it's a much easier application. It goes on great and gives a great flick! But... when trying to re-apply over exisiting line it can rub out and get really awkward to put on. It just doesnt go! It smudges onto the lid after a days wear- always a dark smudge (not too obvious tho).
picked this up as a one off as I couldnt find a reasonably priced eyeliner and straight away loved it, never ever smudges lasts all day, i dont have black around my eyes at the end of the day anymore! would recommend it to anyone and such good value for money!
I was always a little weary of liquid eyeliner, assuming that it would be a nightmare to apply correctly, or that it would only be good for creating the classic Amy Winehouse flick. My previous liquid purchases have been acceptable, but I’ve never preferred them to kohl eyeliner pencils. But when I saw liquid eyeliner in pen form I was intrigued, thinking it would be far easier to use than my previous purchases. Having liquid eyeliner in what is essentially a felt tip pen makes application a hell of a lot easier – you can hold it a lot steadier due to the pen itself being thicker than the more traditional pot eyeliners available. I can create a multitude of looks with this eyeliner, from large flicks and thick lines, to a more neutral and purely defining sweep on my lash line.
OMG this is the best eyeliner I've ever had! I use it everyday it's great just on its own for work or it's fabulous when it's used whilst having smokey eyes! Would never go back to any other eyeliners I told my mum about it and now she uses it as well haha! Amazing buy, well worth the money and would reccomens it to anyone an everyone xxxxx
I am rubbish at doing liquid eyeliner, but this is a really well shapped felt pen eyeliner.
I can do the lines in 15 seconds flat! Really great product and it doesnt smudge or move but is easy to get off and corect if you do happen to make a mistake!
The felt end doesnt get worn or loose its point like other brands.
Great value for money. I will never buy another liquid eyeliner.
Just need some more colours now!!!!
LOVE this product, it dries really fast. Thick coverage. It is so easy to use.
Never had any luck before with liquid eyeliners, but this one Supercat is amazing, goes on easy , stays put all day and looks fabulous, I adore it and wont use any other eye pencil/liquid now and believe me i have tried hundreds
Tried everything else - brushes with gel, pencils, other pens. This one is the bees knees. Straight lines, thin lines, fat lines, flicks - everything possible. You can hold it really well - I think the size has been extremely well tested. And it flows at the right speed. Perfect product.
Never had much luck with liquid eyeliners until i came across this one; so easy to apply and a great finish. highly recommended. love it!
I bought this product yesterday because it had been recommended as 'the best eye liner ever" but I struggle a lot with liquid eye liners so I didn't have much hope. As soon as I got home I tried it out to find it's absolutely amazing! The brush is thin and precise and the liquid doesn't come out in clumps like a lot of eye liners. I would 100% recommend this product, totally worth the money. It's even well priced for the quality of it!:D
Excellent. Used to use the MAC equivalent (£17). This is far superior not to mention almost a third of the price! Please please develop a waterproof version!!
Love this eye liner!!! Relatively new to all the make up 'gadgetry' out there at age 32!!! Love the felt tip pen applicator on this as it makes it so easy to apply and add to if needed. No creasing or dragging so gives a smoothe line really easily! Even my husband has commented on my eyes and that he likes them!! A very rare occurrence!! I am a complete convert to the S & G cosmetic range and have now bought several products in the range. Love them all!! Well done S & G!!!
I'm usually not the type to review make-up, but I had to add to this review! I've always found liquid eyeliner awkward and, quite frankly, messy, but this one is amazing! It doesn't smudge, lasts perfectly all day and is genuinely easy to apply and remove, all for a reasonable price. I'd recommend this to anyone.
I am a big fan and feel the need to stock up on it!
I would definitely recommend it.
I have tried many liquid eyeliners trying to get the look perfectly. I thought I had found the best way of doing it and it involved 3 different ones at once. Until I tried this one, it is so user friendly. It makes it so easy to get the perfect line.
BUY BUY BUY
would recommend to everyone. Before this I had bobby brown gel liner which with the brush cost me about £30 this cost me £6 and it is a million times better it lasts my full 12 hour shifts doesn't crack like most liquid liners, doesn't smudge like a gel ones really easy to use, Ive had a lot of practice with eye liners to get good lines and flicks but I imagine if you are just starting with them the felt tip style end is very easy to use.
I've always been rubbish with liquid liner, even with other pens like this, but not this one, and I love it. So easy to use, stays on incredibly well, but when I want it to come off it does. Fan for life!
Soap & Glory yet again created 8th wonder of the world! This liquid liner is beyond amazing - it is super black, very easy to apply, smudge proof, however easy to take off and looks all natural once applied. And it lasts all day long - fresh and "like it was just applied". Giving it 10 out of 5 stars ;) Great job!
Love it! Makes applying liquid eyeliner so easy!
Really does have a fool proof marker tip! This makes liquid eyeliner really easy to apply (even if you don't have a steady hand!!). Creates both thin and thick lines - love the fact it is a really dark black finish.